1. Electronics

Discuss in my forum

Ninja Gaiden 3 Review (X360)

About.com Rating 3 Star Rating
Be the first to write a review

By , About.com Guide

Ninja Gaiden 3 Review (X360) Tecmo Koei
A lot of folks wondered how a new Ninja Gaiden title would turn out without Tomonobu Itagaki at the helm. Now with Ninja Gaiden 3 we have our answer - pretty freaking poorly. Everything that made the modern Ninja Gaiden games interesting and satisfying and fun is just nowhere to be found here. Ninja Gaiden 3 is a shallow, soulless, easy, rather boring hack and slash that is an undeniable step back from its predecessors. Don't get us wrong, it isn't truly bad or broken or anything, it just isn't Ninja Gaiden anymore, and that is kind of a big problem.
Game Details

  • Publisher: Tecmo Koei
  • Developer: Team Ninja
  • ESRB Rating: “M" for Mature
  • Genre: Action
  • Pros: Decent presentation; co-op; Way easier than past NG games ...
  • Cons: ... a bit too easy; bad camera; shallow combat; no extra weapons; QTEs; story

Ninja Gaiden 3's story centers on Ryu Hayabusa's guilt and internal conflict over the thousands of enemies he's had to kill as well as on his magic right arm that contains the souls of those he's killed that is slowly taking over his free will. Other external things drive the story, of course (Why are we in England, who are these British-y people jabbering in Ryu's ear?), but this is really about Ryu's guilt. Except it is executed in the worst possible way. Ryu is always muttering about whether he is a murderer or not, yet he gladly and willingly kills hundreds more through NG3. At certain points enemies will throw down their weapons, give up fighting, and beg for their lives, yet in order to progress the mission you have to kill them. Hayabusa's magic ninpo attack requires you to kill enough enemies to charge up his evil arm, which then lets you unleash a massive fire dragon that kills even more. The game wildly swings between such extremes of brutality and maudlinity that it just doesn't make sense and also makes it hard for the player to actually care about the super serious story the game is trying to tell.

Gameplay

Tecmo Koei
Who cares about the story, though, right? This is Ninja Gaiden, after all, and crazy gameplay makes up for anything! Not quite. It is kind of Ninja Gaiden-lite. The complex combat system of past games - gone in favor of fairly mindless button mashing against braindead enemies. The wealth of different weapons where each weapon type made the game play dramatically differently - nope, now you just have one sword (more weapons are promised as free DLC, but ... why?). Over the top difficulty expertly balanced to reward skill while never feeling unfair - replaced with dumb, easy enemies that barely put up a fight and difficulty levels where "Hard" in NG3 is like babby mode in NG1 and 2. And, hey, who needs skillful use of projectiles when the game just automatically locks on and you can fling arrows with pinpoint accuracy with no skill at all. Perhaps the strangest thing about NG3 is the over reliance on quick-time-events that pop up pretty constantly (though they are easy and give you tons of time to actually do them). It is like someone at Team Ninja played the atrocious Ninja Blade and, while looking around suspiciously to make double sure Itagaki was really gone, said "Lets make Ninja Gaiden more like Ninja Blade", something that no gamer could have possibly asked for. It is just weird. This isn't Ninja Gaiden.

With all of that said, though, it isn't as if Ninja Gaiden 3 is a bad game. Don't misunderstand the negative tone here. The core controls actually function just fine (though the camera is just as wild and unpredictable as past games), and slicing up enemies is just as crazy and over the top and cinematic and cool as ever (we gotta say, it is still fun to watch others play since it still looks cool even of the gameplay is simple). The problem is that with the gameplay so simplified and watered down and shallow, the once great and unique Ninja Gaiden franchise plays just like every Ninja Gaiden wannabe (like the aforementioned Ninja Blade) instead of retaining the things that made Ninja Gaiden fun and interesting to begin with. If you want an easy hack and slash game, then by all means play Ninja Gaiden 3. You'll have a blast. If you are a fan of past Ninja Gaiden games, however, and if you want a challenge, or depth, or any sense of satisfaction from the videogames you play, NG3 is a letdown.

Features and Modes

Even with our complaints, Ninja Gaiden 3 is kind of mindless fun for a few hours while you play through the single-player campaign. The game also offers online co-op challenge modes along with some competitive modes. Co-op is interesting because it lets you level up and earn new abilities, which makes it slightly better than the SP by default even if it is just arena-style battles. Competitive multiplayer consists of 4v4 team battles where actually hitting anyone is a challenge. The gameplay works fine against dumb A.I. enemies, but when a human foe that can dodge and block and actually avoid your attacks is in front of you, the gameplay just doesn't work as well.

Graphics and Sound

Visually, Ninja Gaiden 3 is a decent looking game. Ryu's character model is nicely detailed and well animated. Enemies aren't as detailed but there are lots of them and the framerate is consistent. Environments and special effects for everything are fine.

The sound is also mostly up to Ninja Gaiden standards. Nice sound effects for all of the hacking and slashing and enemy types you face, appropriate music, and solid voice acting.

Bottom Line

Tecmo Koei
In the end, Ninja Gaiden 3 isn't broken or unplayable, it just isn't really a Ninja Gaiden game anymore. Ninja Gaiden Black is a masterpiece. Ninja Gaiden II is excellent. Ninja Gaiden 3 isn't half the game these two are. Fans of these Japanese-style action games, and fans of Ninja Gaiden in particular, expect a certain level of depth and challenge and satisfaction from the genre, and Ninja Gaiden 3 doesn't deliver. It is shallow and easy and tells a nonsense story that only serves to ruin the pacing and interrupt the brief moments of oldschool joy the game actually does offer. If you are an action game fan, or a Ninja Gaiden fan, stay away. NG3 will only cause you pain. On the other hand, if you liked the premise of past NG games but thought they were too hard, Ninja Gaiden 3 was made just for you. Be warned, though, that out there somewhere, Tomonobu Itagaki is laughing at you (in between bouts of crying about where his franchise has ended up). Skip it.
Disclosure: Review samples were provided by the manufacturer. For more information, please see our Ethics Policy.

©2013 About.com. All rights reserved.