1. Electronics & Gadgets

Discuss in my forum

Viva Piñata Trouble in Paradise Review (X360)

About.com Rating 4.5 Star Rating
Be the first to write a review

By , About.com Guide

Viva Piñata Trouble in Paradise Review (X360)Microsoft
Forget Gears of War 2. Viva Piñata: Trouble in Paradise is the sequel that we’ve been looking forward to in ’08. Thankfully, the wait has been worth it. Trouble in Paradise walks the safe path of not fixing what wasn’t broken, so is looks and plays an awful lot like the original Viva Piñata, but that certainly isn’t a bad thing here. Find out what makes Trouble in Paradise bigger, badder, and more bada** (or, at least as big and bad as cute piñatas can get) right here in our full review.
Quick Hits

  • Title: Viva Piñata: Trouble in Paradise
  • Platform: Xbox 360
  • Publisher: Microsoft
  • Developer: Rare
  • ESRB Rating: “E” for Everyone
  • Genre: Garden Sim
  • Pros: Great graphics; very addictive; tons of stuff to do; surprisingly deep
  • Cons: Not a big change from the original; Piñata Vision ruins the fun

For those new to Viva Piñata, it is all about building a lush garden in the hopes of attracting piñata animals. You can plant grass, dig ponds, and add other knickknacks and doodads in the hope of coaxing wild piñatas in to settle in your garden and become residents. You can then breed your piñatas to make more and try to become a master romancer for a particular species. Piñatas will fight each other or you can smack them with a shovel until they break and the candy spills out. Sound weird? It is, but it is completely addictive and fun. Check out our review of the original VP for all of the details.

Viva Piñata: Trouble in Paradise is more like an expansion pack to the original VP than a full new game. It features all of the piñata types from the first game along with 30+ brand new ones to play with. There are also two new environments you can travel to, a desert and the Arctic, to catch a handful of new piñatas and plants. Local co-op play returns, but you can also now visit other gardens via Xbox Live, which is weird and cool at the same time. Cool because you get to show off, but weird in that it feels very, very, very odd to have other people poking around your garden and messing with stuff.

Gameplay

Microsoft
The core gameplay of Viva Piñata remains the same in Trouble in Paradise, and that is definitely a good thing. Each piñata type has a different set of requirements before they appear, then visit, and then become residents in your garden, and keeping track of all of that is a large part of the fun. Sculpting your garden by planting grass or digging ponds or laying down sand or snow and then building fences and piñata houses (they need somewhere to “romance” y’know) and other things is just incredibly satisfying. Viva Piñata is one of the absolute most rewarding and satisfying games you will ever play because you are constantly rewarded with new piñatas, new plants, new items in the store, and just plain more “stuff”. It will hook you and not let you go until you spend a good 50 hours with it and see and do everything there is to offer. And that is a good thing.

There are a few tweaks in Trouble in Paradise, of course, that make the game a bit better. First up are the new challenges that task you with acquiring a specific piñata and then dressing it up in a specific way or turning it a different color before sending it off to a party. The challenges are nice because they give you a little more direction than the free-for-all that was the original game. Another change comes from the fact that you can access all of your piñatas, seeds, and fertilizer on the main game screen rather than having to go into the menus by pressing left on the d-pad and using the right bumper.

Piñata Vision

The biggest change comes in the cards that you can get off of the Internet and then scan into the game with the Xbox Live Vision camera. These cards give you items in the game or unlock piñatas and place them into your garden. The problem with this, however, is that using the cards completely ruins the fun of the game. If you can just scan a card to unlock the high level and hard to find piñatas, there is no motivation to actually play the game correctly and earn them the right way. If you want to get the true Viva Piñata experience, I highly recommend you do not use the cards.

Graphics

Viva Piñata: TiP is just as gorgeous looking as the original game. The piñatas are extremely cute and cuddly looking and the animations for all of the stuff they do is very good. This game is fun to simply sit back and watch because the piñatas are so funny and cute. The garden is also very lush and vibrant and looks phenomenal. I’m not sure how much of an improvement, if any, the visuals here are over the original, the game still looks absolutely beautiful.

Sound

The sound is also very good in TiP. The piñatas all make distinct and unique sounds so you can tell what is in your garden just by sound. The music is also very good and well suited to the laid back and serene feel of the game. The helper “human” characters could have used a few dozen more lines of spoken dialogue since they repeat themselves a lot, but they aren’t too obnoxious.

Bottom Line

Microsoft
All in all, Viva Piñata: Trouble in Paradise is a solid follow-up to a great game. It takes the safe and easy path of not changing too much, but the foundation it was built upon was so solid to begin with that we don’t really mind. The handful of changes that were made – new piñatas, new environments, Xbox Live co-op, challenges, easier access to your stuff – all really do make Trouble in Paradise a better game overall than the original. The core gameplay of attracting piñatas and breeding them is pretty much identical to before, which is somewhat of a disappointment, but even if you have done all of this before it is still very addictive and rewarding and satisfying and will hook you all over again. My only other real complaint is that the Piñata Vision card scanning stuff kind of breaks the game and ruins a lot of the fun and you are probably better off not using it if you want to keep your experience pure. Other than that, though, Viva Piñata: Trouble in Paradise is a fantastic game that I highly recommend. Don’t be fooled by the cute graphics and goofy premise, this game isn’t just for kids. It offers a ton of depth and strategy that makes it a great game for adults. And an especially great game for adults and kids to play together. Being able to entertain kids and adults, boys and girls, and the whole family together make Trouble in Paradise definitely worthy of a purchase.

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.