1. Home
  2. Electronics & Gadgets
  3. XBox Games

Rock Revolution Review (X360)

About.com Rating 2

By , About.com Guide

Konami
Compare Prices
Remember all of the kids that like to pop up in Rock Band or Guitar Hero discussions and tell you all about how Konami invented the genre with GuitarFreaks and DrumManaia? Well, now you can tell those kids to kindly shut up because Konami’s first attempt at bringing their “expertise” in the genre to the mainstream is a pretty miserable failure. In a world where GH: World Tour and Rock Band 2 exist, Rock Revolution just can’t compete.

Take a look at the Official Rock Revolution Website to see the drums and other information.

Quick Hits

  • Title: Rock Revolution
  • Publisher: Konami
  • Developer: Zoe Mode
  • ESRB Rating: “T” for Teen
  • Genre: Music/Rhythm
  • Pros: $10 cheaper than Rock Band or Guitar Hero; high score focused “arcade” gameplay
  • Cons: Tracks are all covers; gameplay interface is awful; poor drum design

Rock Revolution is Konami’s attempt to get a piece of that sweet, sweet, music/rhythm genre pie that Rock Band and Guitar Hero have been enjoying for the past few years. It features guitar gameplay just like the other games, and all of the Xbox 360 guitars already released are compatible. Konami decided not to release their own guitar, and I would have to say that this was a wise decision considering that most of us already more guitars than we need. Rock Revolution also has drum gameplay that is compatible with both the currently released drums on the market as well as special drums built for the game. Konami’s Rock Revolution drums have 6 pads and a kick pedal, but the layout of the drums is surprisingly complicated and seems to be very hard to use. While GH and RB’s drums make you feel like you are really playing, Rock Revolution’s drums never let you forget that you are playing a videogame. Unlike the other recently released games in the genre, there is no singing feature here.

As far as modes go, Rock Revolution offers everything we have come to expect. There is quick play, career, multiplayer, and a studio mode. Everything is pretty straightforward. The studio mode isn’t nearly as in depth as the one in GH: World Tour, but it isn’t too bad.

Gameplay

Konami
From a purely feature-based perspective, Rock Revolution doesn’t seem too bad. Then you actually start to play it and it all goes downhill. Rock Revolution’s troubles start with the song listing. First, all 41 songs are covers and not the real deal. Secondly, the covers are pretty much awful across the board. And third, you have already played a lot of these songs already in other games.

The gameplay itself is also suspect due to the interface. Rather than coming at you from a ¾ perspective where you have a lot of time to see the notes, the note highway in Rock Revolution is completely vertical, similar to the way the arrows move in Dance Dance Revolution. This only gives you a tiny amount of time to see the notes. Another problem is that the note highway itself is very narrow and kind of hard to see. Similar to how the drums constantly remind you that you are playing a game, the note charts don’t always seem to correspond to the actual music being played. Kind of like how DDR isn’t anything like real dancing. The game likes to use triple notes like they are going out of style. So the charting, the visual look of it, and the interface itself all combine to make Rock Revolution a pain in the butt to play.

One aspect of Rock Revolution that I have to admit I do like is the scoring system. You can easily score a million points in a song, and because of the way the combo and multiplier system works it really feeds that arcade-style “I have to get the highest score possible” OCD-thing that exists in the back of all gamers’ minds.

Graphics and Sound

Graphically, Rock Revolution is an okay looking game. The characters onstage and the venues you play at look fairly decent. The gameplay interface is pretty bad, as I mentioned above, however. It is hard to use, quite frankly. Even stranger is that the high score as well as the audience and star power meters are located in the upper right corner of the screen while the gameplay is mostly happening in the lower left hand corner of the screen. User friendly, it isn’t.

The sound is pretty poor. Like I said, the quality of the covers is pretty bad, which just seems odd when the music is supposed to be pretty much 100% of the appeal.

Bottom Line

Konami
The bottom line on Rock Revolution is that it is about 4 years too late. If this would have been released around the same time or before the first Guitar Hero, it would have been the game to set the world on fire and get all of the acclaim. Instead, we have two other series that have benefited from the last several years of feedback from fans and tweaking and tuning their formulas and Rock Revolution just feels old and out of date even though it is brand new. The interface is awful, the track list is full of covers of songs we have already played before, and the drums leave a lot to be desired. Even for the most die-hard music/rhythm game fans, I can’t recommend Rock Revolution for a purchase. Lets just forget it ever happened.
Compare Prices
User Reviews Write Review

Explore XBox Games

About.com Special Features

Holiday Central

What to eat, where to go, fun things to do and how to save money on the perfect gifts. More >

Family Tech Center

Stay connected and entertained with reviews on tips on the latest HDTVs, cellphones and more. More >

  1. Home
  2. Electronics & Gadgets
  3. XBox Games
  4. Xbox 360 Reviews
  5. Rock Revolution Review (X360)

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.