1. Home
  2. Electronics & Gadgets
  3. XBox Games

NCAA Football 07 Review (Xbox 360)

About.com Rating four out of Five

By Eric Qualls, About.com

EA
Just like all of EA’s other sports games so far, NCAA Football’s first appearance on the Xbox 360 will go down in history as a disappointment. It isn’t a bad game and it looks great and plays just fine, but there is just no logic behind charging $10 extra for a game with less features. For that reason, the Xbox classic version is the one to own, but if you don’t have any other systems, the 360 does a fine job.
Quick Hits

  • Title: NCAA Football 07
  • Platform: Xbox 360
  • Publisher: EA Sports
  • Developer: EA Sports
  • ESRB: “E” for Everyone
  • Genre: College football
  • Pros: Great graphics, fun gameplay, achievements
  • Cons: Glitchy, missing features, stadiums aren’t accurate, costs $60

Features and Modes

The major story in NCAA Football 07 for the Xbox 360 is missing features. You can play single games, dynasty mode, online play, and three minigames and that is it. There is no Campus Legend, spring drills, create-a-school mode, or mascot games from the Xbox version. Why exactly is this version $10 extra? Also, I’m very disappointed to report that not all of the stadiums got the next-gen treatment. The big schools’ stadiums are here, but many schools are represented by the same generic stadium. Sure, the field the Boise State Broncos play on is blue in the game, but that sure as heck isn’t Bronco Stadium. In fact, none of the 4 stadiums I have been to in real life are in the game, and that is a major bummer. One of the fun things about games like this is being able to see your campus represented in the game and that just doesn’t happen here for most schools.

Gameplay

EA
The gameplay is one area where the 360 version stands up very well to the last generation versions. I find the controls to be a little bit tighter and better overall and I greatly prefer the play calling in the 360 version. It also has to be noted that the 360 version is actually easier to play simply because the graphics are better. You can see everything so much more clearly that you are able to react faster and play better.

The 360 version has some glitches that the other versions do not have, however, which definitely hurts it. You will experience a ton of phantom pass interference calls and there is nothing you can do about it. I have also noticed a lot of catches made a step out of bounds that are allowed to stand even when I challenge them. I also have at least one play per game that is almost certainly a forward pass but is called a fumble. Annoying? Absolutely. Deal breakers? Not really.

Graphics and Sound

As I mentioned above, the graphics really do make a big difference in this game. Everything is so sharp and clear that it actually makes you play better. The crowd is also easily the best looking crowd in any sports game to date, which isn’t a huge deal but is something you’ll definitely notice. I also absolutely love the fact that the lighting changes as the game goes on. Starting a game in the afternoon sun and having it gradually darken to sunset and then playing under the lights is really, really cool. Once you see and play the 360 version, it is really hard to go back to the Xbox version. There is that big of a difference.

The sound is pretty much the same as the other versions of the game. Good stadium sound, decent commentary from Nessler, Herbstreit, and Corso, and the same good school fight songs. The sound effects for the action on the field seem to be better on the 360, however, and the crunch of a big hit is pretty satisfying here.

Bottom Line

EA
Overall, the Xbox 360 version of NCAA Football 07 is a good game, but it is hard to justify spending the extra $10 when it doesn’t have nearly as many features as the other versions. It looks good and plays good and, personally, I feel that once you experience this version you won’t want to go back, but the value just isn’t here. If you have an Xbox, that version is definitely the one to get. But if you only have an Xbox 360 and are desperate for some college football, you’ll be pretty darn happy with this one. NCAA Football 07 is a great game and I highly recommend it no matter what system you get it on.
Compare Prices

Explore XBox Games

More from About.com

  1. Home
  2. Electronics & Gadgets
  3. XBox Games
  4. Xbox 360 Reviews
  5. NCAA Football 07 Review (Xbox 360)

©2008 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.