1. Home
  2. Electronics & Gadgets
  3. XBox Games

All-Pro Football 2K8 Review (X360)

About.com Rating threehalf out of Five

By Eric Qualls, About.com

2K Sports
Back in the summer of 2004, 2K Sports rolled out NFL 2K5 at a bargain price of just $20. It was arguably the best football game yet. EA countered this threat by simply eliminating it by snatching up exclusive rights to the NFL license, and 2K’s brand of football just disappeared for a few years. Now in 2007, 2K is back with All-Pro Football 2K8. Does the 2K style still hold up after three years? And can a roster of legends on fake teams compete with the real NFL? Find out in our full review.
Quick Hits

  • Title: All-Pro Football 2K8
  • Platform:Xbox 360
  • Publisher: 2K Sports
  • Developer: Visual Concepts
  • ESRB Rating: “E” for Everyone
  • Genre: Football
  • Pros: Great animation; solid gameplay
  • Cons: Not terribly different from NFL 2K5; poor value at $60; list of all-pro players isn’t that spectacular

Features

Since Madden has the NFL license, 2K had to do something different. Rather than completely manufacture everything from the ground up like Midway did with Blitz: The League, All-Pro Football 2K8 instead makes use of a group of 200+ NFL legends and puts them on made up teams. You start the game by creating your own custom team. You have slots for two gold level legends, three silver, and six bronze, and then the rest of your team is filled in by generic players. You can also customize your team logo and colors so you can make it all however you want. Unfortunately, the single-player aspect is extremely limited and there are only quick play and season modes. For online multiplayer, though, there are many more options including seasons and tournaments for up to 32 teams, and since everyone has custom teams, there is a ton of variety and it can be very interesting.

I do have some issues with all of this, though. First off, the list of legends actually isn’t all that impressive outside of the immediately recognizable names. There are just way too many guys on here that most people won’t recognize, or just flat out aren’t legend caliber, which makes filling out your team, particularly with bronze players, somewhat difficult and less exciting than it should be.

Gameplay

2K Sports
The gameplay is pretty much what you remember from NFL 2K5, which is both a good thing and a bad thing. It still offers more realistic passing where you can easily pump fake and your quarterback has to have his feet planted to throw the ball effectively, and it still has a great running game, but it is all pretty much exactly the same as it was three years ago. Now, that isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but consider this. Back in 2004, there wasn’t really any question that the gameplay in 2K5 was better than Madden 2005. In the years since then, however, pretty much every aspect of the gameplay in Madden has gotten better while 2K has stayed mostly the same. From the pure feel of the game, to ease of play, to countless little intangibles, I think Madden/NCAA plays better than All-Pro Football 2K8. I’m not saying 2K8 doesn’t play great, I’m just saying that Madden has finally caught up.

Graphics and Sound

Graphically, All-Pro Football 2K8 isn’t all that impressive. It literally looks like little more than a juiced up copy of NFL 2K5. There is more details in the jerseys and helmets and stadiums than before, and everything is in HD obviously, but compared to EA’s football games it looks pretty outdated. I have never been a fan of the strange looking player models where they seem too tall and too skinny and particularly the upper torso seems stretched, and that same style is fully intact here. Also, the faces of the players, coaches, and referees all look pretty horrible.

One very bright spot that I noticed immediately was the animation. This is one of the best animated sports games out there, and it has a lot of little things that you’ll notice and really appreciate. Things such as the blocking and play on the line seems much more realistic than before. Unlike other games where the lineman just hook up like they are connected with magnets, in 2K8 they actually look like they are grabbing and pushing and pulling eachother. Tackling also looks really spectacular.

The sound is also somewhat of a letdown, simply because of how much of it was reused from 2K5. The announcing team of Dan Stevens and Peter O'Keefe return with all of the same lame jokes and goofy commentary as before. There are different player names here, but you can’t help but think you have heard all of this before. The sounds on the field are pretty much what you’d expect from a football game.

Bottom Line

2K Sports
Overall, All-Pro Football 2K8 is a decent enough game of football, but it falls short for several reasons. First off, it is a bit of a stinger that we got a fully featured, officially licensed NFL game for $20 in NFL 2K5, and yet they want to charge us a full $60 for an unlicensed game where the feature list is definitely lacking in All-Pro Football 2K8. That dog won’t hunt, monsignor. Also, the gameplay and presentation really haven’t been updated from the game we all played three years ago. It isn’t bad, but it also doesn’t hold up very well to Madden and NCAA football from EA that have improved significantly over the past three years. All-Pro Football 2K8 is a decent game of football that fans of the series will certainly enjoy, but it absolutely isn’t the game that finally sticks it to EA like a lot of people wanted. It is outdated, overpriced, and ultimately a letdown. Rent it first.
Compare Prices

Explore XBox Games

More from About.com

  1. Home
  2. Electronics & Gadgets
  3. XBox Games
  4. Xbox 360 Reviews
  5. All-Pro Football 2K8 Review (X360)

©2008 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.